The desk
Which onion?
The Royal Horticultural Society publishes official growing guides for onions, shallots and salad onions. Encyclopaedia Britannica has its own official page, with commercial types and a history. This desk quotes them in turn, and does not flatten them into one crop. [source] [source] [source] [source]
Which onion?
Pick a story. The Royal Horticultural Society keeps official growing guides for onions, shallots and salad onions. Encyclopaedia Britannica has its own official page, with a history, a flower, and a reason the kitchen makes you cry. Official figures that disagree are kept on their own lines.


| The official crop | What official pages say |
|---|---|
| Storage onions, yellow, white or red | The Society: many varieties, producing yellow, white or red onions, some spicy and tangy, others mild and sweet. Grown from sets or seed; spring-planted or seed-raised bulbs are ready from July to October and can last until well into the following spring. |
| Overwintering or Japanese onions | Autumn sets, usually sold as overwintering or Japanese onions, for an earlier crop. Ready in June and July; they store until early winter. |
| Shallots | The Society: Allium cepa Aggregatum Group, a type of small, sweet onion. One set produces a cluster of new bulbs. They generally store for at least six to eight months. Britannica: a small, angular variety of onion. Both official wordings are kept. |
| Salad onions, also called spring onions and scallions | The Society groups the three names as one crop, varieties of Allium cepa or Allium fistulosum, sown little and often. Britannica gives separate official sizes for spring onions (25–38 mm) and for green onions, also called scallions (13 mm or less). Those official lists stay apart. |
A brown storage bulb and a red one are, in the Society’s garden, still Allium cepa — different official colours of the same official species. [source] Shallots and salad onions have their own official guides, and their own official surprises, on the shallot page and the salad-onion page. The figures that disagree — two official heights, two official ways to grow a commercial crop and a garden crop, two official scallion stories — are walked through in the field notes.
Enjoyed this desk of sets, shallots, and a store that wants the light?
No pop-ups. No intrusive advertising. Just interesting stuff. A little support helps the next vegetables.im site get built.