Explore vegetables.im

Myths versus facts

Twelve claims, and what the official pages actually say

Each myth is a tidy sentence a careful reader might walk away with, if official wording were blended, or treated as all one voice.

Myth. You should bend the leaves over, or lift the bulbs to break the roots, to help them ripen.

The official pages say: The Royal Horticultural Society says that although this is sometimes suggested, this is no longer recommended. The official sign of maturity is yellowing and toppling of the foliage.

Myth. Store onions in the dark, like potatoes.

The official pages say: The Society's onion and shallot guides both say to keep them in a light, cool, dry, well-ventilated place. Don't store in the dark, as this encourages sprouting.

Myth. Shallots are a completely different official species from the onion.

The official pages say: The Society calls shallots Allium cepa Aggregatum Group, a type of small, sweet onion. Encyclopaedia Britannica describes them as a small, angular variety of onion. This desk does not invent a third official species name.

Myth. Salad onion, spring onion and scallion are officially three different crops in the RHS guides.

The official pages say: The Society's salad-onion guide says salad onions are also called spring onions and scallions, and are varieties of Allium cepa or Allium fistulosum. Encyclopaedia Britannica keeps separate official sizes for spring onions and for green onions, also called scallions. Those official wordings are not blended.

Myth. Chopping onions makes you cry because of a kitchen myth, not because of anything official.

The official pages say: The tears are in official wording. Encyclopaedia Britannica says a sulfur-rich volatile oil, released during peeling or chopping, brings tears to the eyes.

Myth. There is one official height for an onion plant.

The official pages say: Encyclopaedia Britannica gives leafless flower stalks of 75-180 cm (2.5-6 feet). The Society's Allium cepa profile gives a maximum height of 0.1-0.5 metres. Those official figures are not averaged.

Myth. Onions are officially native to Britain.

The official pages say: Encyclopaedia Britannica says the onion is likely native to southwestern Asia, and that the Romans introduced it to Britain. The Society's profile, under Native to GB/Ireland, says No.

Myth. The easiest official way to grow onions, everywhere, is from seed.

The official pages say: The Society, writing for a British garden, says sets are the easiest and fastest way. Encyclopaedia Britannica, describing commercial crops, says most are grown from small black seeds. Both official practices are kept.

Myth. Onion seeds last as well as other vegetable seeds, officially, for many years.

The official pages say: The Society says onion seeds don't stay viable for long, with germination rates declining after a year or two.

Myth. The onion's official name comes, without doubt, from the Latin unus.

The official pages say: Encyclopaedia Britannica says the name is probably derived from the Latin unus, meaning one. The official probably is part of the fact.

Myth. Onions are officially a medicine for colds, earaches and warts.

The official pages say: Encyclopaedia Britannica records that curative powers have been attributed to onions throughout the centuries in folk medicine. That is historical official wording, not a medical claim, and not advice from this site.

Myth. This site is an official RHS or Britannica page.

The official pages say: It is independent, and is not affiliated with or endorsed by either. Official wording is quoted from the pages listed in the sources.

Keep the lights on

Enjoyed this desk of sets, shallots, and a store that wants the light?

No pop-ups. No intrusive advertising. Just interesting stuff. A little support helps the next vegetables.im site get built.