Field notes
Useless’s field notes: the figures that do not quite agree
Most of this site is told as a story. The nuances live here, so official pages are not quietly rewritten into a smoother crop.
Two official heights
Encyclopaedia Britannica: leafless flower stalks “reach a height of 75–180 cm (2.5–6 feet).” [source] The Allium cepa profile: maximum height 0.1–0.5 metres, maximum spread 0.1–0.5 metres. [source] Those official figures may describe different official ways of talking about a leafy bulb and a flowering stalk. This desk does not decide which, and does not average them.
Sets in the garden, seed in the field
The Society, for a British garden, says onions are usually grown from sets, “the easiest and fastest way.” [source] Britannica, of commercial crops, says most “are grown from the plant’s small black seeds, which are sown directly in the field,” though they may also be grown from small bulbs or transplants. [source] Both official practices are kept.
Two official scallion stories
The Society’s salad-onion guide: salad onions, “also called spring onions and scallions,” are varieties of Allium cepa or Allium fistulosum. [source] Britannica: spring onions picked at 25–38 mm; green onions, also called scallions, harvested at 13 mm or less. [source] The official “or Allium fistulosum” is not used to rewrite Britannica’s onion-page entries, and Britannica’s millimetres are not used to split the Society’s three-name crop into three official species.
Two official shallot descriptions
The Society: Allium cepa Aggregatum Group, “a type of small, sweet onion,” with a cluster from one set. [source] Britannica: “a small, angular variety of onion.” [source] Neither official wording is used to correct the other.
A profile that says shallots, on the onion page
The Allium cepa profile says: “Yellowing and toppling of the foliage is a sign that the shallots are reaching maturity. Lift and store in a cool dry place.” [source] The word “shallots” is the profile’s own wording, and is kept as written. The onion growing guide, on harvest, says the same of “the crop,” and adds that stored bulbs should be kept in the light. [source] The profile’s “cool dry place” is not treated as permission to ignore the light.
A native range, and a no
Britannica’s “likely native to southwestern Asia” and “the Romans introduced the onion to Britain” are not rewritten as a British native range. [source] The profile’s Native to GB/Ireland: No, is not rewritten as a disagreement with an introduction. [source]
Probably, and probably again
Official wording uses “probably” for a pre-history in India, China and the Middle East, and “probably” for a derivation from Latin unus. [source] Those official hedges stay in the sentences.
Folk medicine is official history, not advice
Britannica records that curative powers “have been attributed to onions throughout the centuries.” [source] This site quotes that history and does not offer treatments, doses, or a nutrient claim. Official wording that onions “are low in nutrients but are valued for their flavour” stays with its page. [source]
Enjoyed this desk of sets, shallots, and a store that wants the light?
No pop-ups. No intrusive advertising. Just interesting stuff. A little support helps the next vegetables.im site get built.